Setting a validated science-based target isn't something to attempt the moment a client asks for one. It requires a specific combination of data, internal alignment, and operational understanding, and companies that skip ahead without those pieces in place often end up paying for the same work twice.
The data requirement, by track
The data a company needs depends on which track they're pursuing. Companies on the SME or Category B pathway need a complete Scope 1 and Scope 2 footprint, along with a commitment to begin tracking Scope 3 emissions over time. Companies pursuing the corporate track need a fully comprehensive footprint that covers every relevant Scope 3 category, submitted in full through the SBTi portal.
Base year selection matters just as much as the completeness of the data itself. Companies choose their own base year, and that choice becomes the anchor point for every future reduction target. It's common, and advisable, to avoid years affected heavily by pandemic-related disruptions, since unusually low activity during that period doesn't reflect a company's typical operations. A base year should be recent enough to be relevant and comprehensive enough to represent the business accurately, since setting a target against a distorted number creates a harder, less meaningful path forward rather than an easier one.
The mistake that costs the most time and money
The most common issue companies run into isn't a rejected submission. It's inaccurate or incomplete data. Many companies attempt their footprint using a free calculator or software tool that produces a number that looks complete but isn't. Because that number tends to run lower than a comprehensive footprint would, the target gets built around an inaccurate, artificially reduced baseline.
The consequences show up later, and they're expensive. If a baseline needs to be recalculated, whether because SBTi flags the data as insufficiently supported or because a company realizes on its own that something was missed, the cost of redoing that data collection is generally the same as doing it correctly the first time. On top of re-collecting the data, the company will also need to resubmit its targets to SBTi and pay the validation fees again. That's true whether a company has a dedicated sustainability function or not. Even teams with a sustainability lead on staff usually manage several other responsibilities at once, and time spent re-baselining a target is time not spent on the broader work that person was hired to do.
What SBTi is actually looking for during validation
SBTi rarely rejects a submission outright. More often, they request more information: additional context on planned reduction initiatives, clarification on which emissions factors were used and why, or more detailed documentation supporting the methodology behind the numbers. This is a standard part of the validation process, not a sign of failure, and it reflects that SBTi puts its name behind every target it validates. Ensuring the data follows the Greenhouse Gas Protocol and that every validated company uses a consistent methodology is the whole point of that back-and-forth.
What readiness actually looks like
Beyond the data itself, a handful of factors determine whether a company is genuinely ready to pursue a validated target, regardless of the track.
Executive buy-in. A target can't meaningfully drive change inside an organization if the decision-makers aren't part of that conversation. Reduction initiatives require operational changes, and operational changes require someone with the authority to approve them. Without leadership involvement from the start, a target risks becoming a document rather than a plan.
Data, or a credible plan to get there. Category B companies need their Scope 1 and Scope 2 data in hand before setting a target. Corporate track companies need a clear plan for capturing comprehensive data across all Scope 3 categories, since that track includes a formal multi-year commitment to build that data out.
Data that's actually comprehensive. Estimates aren't disqualifying on their own, but a target built entirely on stacked estimates isn't the same as one built on verified data, and SBTi will flag submissions where that becomes apparent. Good data takes more time upfront, and that time is part of what makes a target durable rather than something that needs revisiting later.
A real understanding of how the business operates. SBTi asks companies to outline initiatives for how they intend to reach their targets. Without a working understanding of how the company's operations, facilities, and processes actually function, it's difficult to identify realistic reduction levers rather than generic, disconnected ideas that don't reflect what's actually achievable.
None of these are hard requirements like headcount or revenue thresholds. But a company missing several of them isn't in a strong position to submit a target that will hold up through validation, or one that will meaningfully drive change once it's in place.
How this compares to EcoVadis
SBTi and EcoVadis serve different purposes, and people sometimes confuse them because they often come up in the same conversations. SBTi is a target-setting initiative focused specifically on emissions reduction. EcoVadis is a broader disclosure and scoring platform covering environmental, social, and governance performance, resulting in a badge that reflects overall ESG maturity rather than a specific reduction commitment.
The two connect in a useful way. EcoVadis includes a section specifically on carbon emissions, and a company that has already gone through the SBTi process typically has that data ready to go. EcoVadis also asks directly whether a company has a validated SBTi target, and having one earns additional points in the environmental portion of the assessment, which can meaningfully improve the overall badge a company receives. Companies pursuing both aren't duplicating work. Completing SBTi first often makes the EcoVadis process more straightforward.
Readiness for SBTi isn't about being a large company or a particular type of business. It's about having internal alignment and data discipline in place before the process starts, since both are far easier to build ahead of time than to retrofit mid-validation.
FAQ
-
Category B companies need a complete Scope 1 and Scope 2 footprint plus a commitment to track Scope 3 over time. Corporate track companies need a comprehensive footprint covering all relevant Scope 3 categories before submission.
-
Using inaccurate or incomplete data, often from a free calculator, to set the baseline. If that data has to be corrected later, the cost of redoing the work is typically the same as doing it right the first time.
-
SBTi is focused specifically on setting a validated emissions reduction target. EcoVadis is a broader ESG disclosure and scoring platform, and having a validated SBTi target can improve a company's EcoVadis score in the environmental section.